This event warrants more awareness for posterity.

First and foremost, I make no apologies for the Xzibit-esque title. It's for the contextual linking, init.

A chap in Hurstpierpoint picked up a chip on his windscreen. Although the marque is irrelevant, not all windscreen replacements are equal; some require more specialist attention than others; in this case: a Porsche Cayman 718. He contacted his insurer and he was immediately connected to their nominated repairer (they repair as well as replace). A consultation took place which led to the repairer's decision that a replacement would be necessary. The reason given: 'the chip is on a curved part of the windscreen'.

With a few exceptions, the overwhelming majority of windscreens are curved. Our chap deferred and started a thread on an owner's club forum to gauge opinion.

After a second opinion from the people who repair (the people who also replace) it was confirmed that the damage did not meet the repair criteria (their criteria). The ensuing discussion prompted the gentleman to arranging an appointment to have the windscreen replaced. That conversation took a twist of its own when he asked if the windscreen would be an original, 'OEM' part and was told that they're all the same (plus or minus a stamp). He insisted on an authentic Porsche part if he was to agree. At that point he was told he would be subject to a supplement. This was not discussed before policy inception (he couldn't see it anywhere in the Policy Schedule or Key Facts which would have been pre-disclosed so that he could make an informed decision about the proposal). Furthermore, anyone asked to pay a supplement is on a loser immediately on the basis that there is no indicator to what the repair and replace people would be charging for an aftermarket windscreen. For the record, he was told he would have to pay c£800 which was quantified as the difference. Guess how much a new Cayman windscreen - for that MY - is to buy from Porsche?

Mr Cayman understandably wasn't comfortable. The matter came to my attention and I was asked for advice.

Paying a supplement for a genuine part was clearly a contentious issue. It was also unreasonable; potentially in breach of the terms as there was no indication of it anywhere in the policy. As much as there was a case in that respect, it didn't need to get that far; the damage was repairable: in terms of the overall size; its position; the type of break, and its age, all indicated a viable repair.

The people who repair and the people who replace follow standards set by the BSI who produce technical standards, certification, and standards-related services to businesses. However, each individual assessment is made (on behalf of the relevant underwriter) by the attending technician (some of the assessments are done online by way of a few questions). If there is a reason which he or she feels does not justify or warrant a repair, he or she will advise a replacement. It might be that the damage does not meet the repair criteria, or there may be another reason which 'might' come from the covert code of practice pamphlet: Doing What's Best for You.

Meanwhile, Mr Cayman agreed to my offer of a repair. He didn't fancy the odds given to him about replacing the windscreen but in any case, it's a viable repair, so why not? His windscreen got the stay of execution he was hoping for and once complete, he was pleased with the result.

In terms of the cost, I suggested that he should be seeking reimbursement from his insurance company. They not only should be covering it, but should also be delighted to pay it. Nope. They offered him 40% of the invoice as a gesture.

This episode did not favour the consumer in any way whatsoever. He was told the chip cannot be repaired. He was then told the replacement would cost him an extra 800-odd pounds sterling - additional to his policy excess - if he wanted an authentic Porsche part. Given that he's had the damage repaired - at a fraction of the cost - the insurance company are not prepared pay for it because the work was not done by their nominated repairer (!) and for that reason, they would only contribute a small part of it as a gesture of goodwill (their way of trying to keep him sweet enough for renewal).

After the work was done, Mr Cayman - a retired gentleman - decided against accepting the few quid offered by his insurer (it wasn't worth it) and also valued his time more than trying to argue with them about the whole matter. The reality is that most will move on and not bother with asking any pertinent questions. The insurance parties carry on regardless and the repairers live to fight another day.

Far too many windscreens are replaced when a repair would have been the viable, economical and most sensible option.